Few foods have been bad-mouthed like carbs. Bread, rice, pasta and potatoes have been blamed for everything from belly fat to bad moods, and plenty of people have tried swearing them off.
So this week’s ghost is a big one. If you want to lose fat, cut the carbs.
Why Everyone Believes It
Because the first week works like magic. Cut carbs and the scale can drop five pounds almost overnight. But remember two weeks ago, when we talked about glycogen? Your body stores carbs with roughly three grams of water per gram. Cut the carbs, lose the water, and the scale celebrates. It just isn’t fat. Eat a sandwich and a good chunk of it comes right back, which convinces people carbs are making them fat. They’re not. They’re making you hydrated.
The Scary Truth
When calories are equal, cutting carbs doesn’t beat cutting fat. Stanford tested this in a year-long study of over 600 adults. One group ate a healthy low-carb diet, the other a healthy low-fat diet. After twelve months, the average difference in weight loss between the two groups was about a pound and a half. Not statistically meaningful. Both groups lost weight for the same reason, they ate less.
An NIH study run in a lab, where every bite was measured, found something even more surprising. At the same calorie cut, the low-fat diet led to slightly more body fat loss than the low-carb one.
Carbs aren’t the villain. Too many calories are. Carbs just happen to show up in a lot of the foods that are easiest to overeat.
The Real Troublemakers
Look closely at the foods people blame on carbs. Donuts, chips, pizza, cookies, fries. Almost every one is carbs and fat together, which is the combo our brains find almost impossible to stop eating. Nobody’s eating a whole bag of plain baked potatoes. In fact, in one well-known study ranking how filling foods are, boiled potatoes came out on top, beating everything from steak to fish.
Carbs also fuel your training. Lift on an empty tank for long enough and your workouts start to feel heavy in all the wrong ways.
Your Move This Week
- Keep the carbs, size the portion. A cupped handful of rice, pasta or potatoes per meal is a good starting point for most people.
- Pick the fiber-rich ones most of the time. Oats, beans, fruit, potatoes and whole grains. Most adults get about half the fiber they need, and fiber only comes from carbs.
- Put your carbs around your workouts, where they actually help you train harder.
- Watch the carb-plus-fat combos. That’s where the calories pile up, not the potato.
Tuesday’s cornbread is officially off the hook. The fourth topping on the chili, though, is still under investigation.
Michael Wilkie
Aspire Health & Fitness
